certain stores making prices too high

topic posted Tue, January 17, 2006 - 6:14 PM by  Richard
in particular Goodwill here in Cinti.
posted by:
Richard
Cincinnati
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Wed, January 18, 2006 - 5:23 PM
    I hate Goodwill. Their prices are always too high. I saw a pair of, not designer but still named bran, slacks for sale at GW for like $12. I could buy a similar pair, brand new, at Ross for the same price. Rip off.
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Wed, January 18, 2006 - 6:20 PM
      Yeah, it bites, and Goodwill's the worst. Things are a little better in my neck of the woods, but not much. And whoever's marking the prices at a lot of those stores is going by some sort of half-assed system: $15 for a ratty old Vuitton purse because it's a Vuitton, except it really isn't a Vuitton, but a knockoff. And as you've noticed, jeans are also up for the price gouge: a pair of paint-stained jeans for $20 because they're Calvins. But even the non-designer items are getting more and more pricey.

      I have more than once wondered if the price hikes are because the stores figure a lot of people are reselling the stuff on eBay and they want a piece of the action.
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Wed, January 18, 2006 - 9:01 PM
        I'm sure that's part of the reason for the price hikes...but when they hike up 'regular' stuff or nicer/brand-name things in bad condition it's just ridiculous. Makes me stop shopping there on a regular basis. And have you seen what Goodwill silent auction items go for? It's crazy what people will pay for collectibles (course it can be said about ebay, too).

        I do like to hit up sale days though at some thrifts that may seem a bit overpriced normally...there's one called Thrift Center in SJ which has a few racks of nicer items of clothing. I recently scored some unique and interesting clothing items and accessories on sale from perusing those racks, which was fun. :)
        • Re: certain stores making prices too high

          Thu, January 19, 2006 - 8:48 AM
          In my area (NorthEastern PA), Goodwill was the one with the low prices; they'd also take counter-offers. Salvation Army generally has absolutely ridiculous prices on G-d-awful furniture, yet still somehow seems to sell it.

          Goodwill closed down regionally a few years back. :::sigh:::
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Wed, June 7, 2006 - 12:14 PM
        Yesterday A fellow at the local Goodwill told me they are raising !^! book prices to $3!!
        I said ~!!!WwwHaaatt!?!?
        & he said
        "... they want to be sure to keep the appearance of being 'not for profit'... not!"
        Next door at the Von's people drop off their used books & you can buy them for $2 donated to a local organization or to Cancer research.
        & I wonder if the notGoodwill knows that you can get books you actually want & are interested in on the internet for really cheap as opposed to just buying something you might read someday for more~~~
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Sun, August 13, 2006 - 11:03 PM
        <<<I have more than once wondered if the price hikes are because the stores figure a lot of people are reselling the stuff on eBay and they want a piece of the action.>>>>

        One of the managers at the Goodwill I visit told me that they check to see what something is selling for on Ebay and then price it according to that. But I don't bother them too much on pricing because they still don't have a clue. Their pricing can still be very sporadic.
        For example: A cheap painting on plastic type canvas which was selling at Hobby Lobby for 19.99 had a 60.00 price written on the back of it.
        A knock off Prada was on display for 50.00. When I tried to show them that it was a fake, they looked at me like I was from outer space.

        BUT!!!
        I have found the following steals:
        Two Edelstahl pots, mint condition for 2.02 each.
        A Hall China water caraffe for 6.06.
        A set of 23 cups, 23 saucers Pickard China for 6.06
        A Basketville basket, new with tag for 4.04.
        A Petersboro basket for 2.02
        A set of 8 practically new Vera(pre-ladybug) napkins for 65cents each.
        Six Syracuse China cups for 55cents each.
        Four Syracuse China restaurant cups. 55cents each.
        A set of six Southern Railway highball glasses, very good condition, 55cents each.
        An Ilise Stevens (vintage) short pegnoir set, mint condition for 5.85.
        Two Stone Mountain purses for 2.60 each.

        I did not buy a vintage mint condition Young Edwardian mini dress for 5.85, and later discovered that label selling on the internet for 25-50 dollars.

        Anyway... The Goodwills near me are not as savvy as they think they are, and that's OK with me.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Thu, January 19, 2006 - 9:47 PM
    Yah, it is funny what Goodwill totally overprices - then they underprice something stunning - I picked up a fabulous Crane walnut wood pen (and paper) box, today, with green velvet felt lining... lovely... great for my antique fountain pens...
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Tue, January 24, 2006 - 5:26 PM
      i try not to go to Goodwill if I can help it.
      I am lucky to live in the vicinity of two decent thrifty stores with pretty good prices.
      I am very spoiled...then there is the Jr. Forum place that is a total rip-off on alot of stuff...though they HAD a 50-cent rack with a suprisingly good selection...i guess until they realised that people were just going there for the 50-cent rack.
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Wed, February 1, 2006 - 2:11 PM
        I've come to the conclusion that the management of Goodwill has shifted their attention to different niche in the market. I've also noticed several Goodwill stores selling their stuff to the online shoppers, too.

        Salvation Army furniture is usually pretty beaten up, but now and then they have good stuff. I got a pretty good desk from them which I still have--very well-built and sturdy. Now and then they also sell handmade bookcases from unfinished wood.

        SA books are good, too, usually for 25-50¢ each.
        • Re: certain stores making prices too high

          Wed, June 28, 2006 - 10:33 AM
          TE wrote:
          I've come to the conclusion that the management of Goodwill has shifted their attention to different niche in the market.

          Yup...that's exactly it. The latest thing around here is for the yuppie princesses from the upscale 'burbs to go slumming to the thrift stores in poorer neighborhoods. I hate that!!!!! The Goodwill managers see dollar signs and raise their prices. And the people who really need the cheap stuff are suffering because places like Goodwill...and in my area, Unique Thrift Stores (Purple Heart Vets)...are raising their prices considerably. On some things, you can go to Wal-Mart and buy new stuff cheaper.

          ARGGHH!!!! I HATE YUPPIES!!!!!

          WW
          • Re: certain stores making prices too high

            Thu, June 29, 2006 - 7:17 PM
            The Goodwill's in the midwest have been getting surplus from target .. So they have new stuff but they are charging a whole lot for it .. If you catch the same stuff at Target on clearence you can get it from 2-5 bucks .. once it goes to Goodwill the same things cost 5-12 ..
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: certain stores making prices too high

            Wed, November 29, 2006 - 10:33 AM
            So, just because someone has the money to do so they are OBLIGED to buy new stuff? If I decide that I'd rather not waste the resources, and that I want to go to the trift store, it's my fault that the thrift store owners are jacking the prices? No matter what their motivation might be I'd rather see the "yuppie princesses" buying used clothing that's already had its environmental and ethical impact, rather than insisting on brand new made in china every two months.

            What really bugs me, is that the thrifts stores don't actually make more money by doing this --- they make the same money for selling fewer things, and more clothing that could have been reused ends up in landfill so that they can turn over their stock and make space for new donations.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Mon, February 20, 2006 - 10:15 PM
    I've jumped to the conclusion that the price is higher because of the monthly 1/2 price day. Both Goodwill and VV in my area have a monthly 1/2 off day. They may be figuring if you really want it and can't wait -you'll pay the crazy price?
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Tue, April 18, 2006 - 1:28 PM
      I agree with you all about goodwill, but even more frustrating is the fact that they are one company yet they have different price structures/sales depending on the area. For example I lived in phoenix and they have two half price days a month for the whole store. Here in CA they used to have tag sales-like blue tag 1/2 off ect but even now they are starting to change that. But the one thing is that in ca most of the stores have set price like jeans are 6.95 and shirts are 3.95 ect. So It seems like some of the pricing is determined by the area and what they think people will pay. Like in stockton its a lot cheaper, but they never have any sales.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Fri, April 21, 2006 - 4:28 PM
    Goodwill in Claifornia is overpriced too, I thought it was Isolated to the Bay Area. Pretty much every thrift store in the city of San Francisco is a rip off. The worst one I think is called Idol Vintage, and it sells clothes by the pound. it must be like $50 a pound because I bought 2 small things there once and it cost $14! I was too embarassed to protest, but I should have. The clothes were in lousy condition, too. I was turned off thrifting altogether until I found Savers.
    • good thrift stores are hard to find...

      Sun, May 28, 2006 - 10:41 AM
      If you can find a non-chain-store thrift store that supports a cause of some sort, those are usually the best. Try going thru the phone book, searching yellow pages online, heck even keeping your eyes open when driving around. There are still some around.

      Too bad St. Vincent de Paul stores are gone from the bay area, as far as I can tell. Those were great stores!
      • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

        Sun, May 28, 2006 - 2:29 PM
        The best chain here is called Unique Thrift Shops. Some of their stuff can be overpriced, but they do have half-off days (which I avoid--too crazy), plus they color-code their tags so that almost everything is reduced by half after a week.

        I picked up a pair of 4-wheel skates yesterday that I would have been perfectly happy to pay $8 for--didn't even notice the yellow tag that made them only $4!

        I find Unique has the best selection for this area and that, yes, Salvation Army stuff tends to be in worse shape and Goodwill higher-priced. But what I love about thrifting is that if you know your stuff you'll always find the good stuff that they underprice because they don't recognize it.

        Many times I've found cashmere and silk items for cheap just because the tags weren't that prominent but I know what good fabric looks and feels like.

        Same thing with books--they might overprice a later edition of a Harry Potter book because it's a hot name, but they'll miss a first edition of Lawrence Ferlinghetti.

        I live for the hunt!
      • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

        Mon, May 29, 2006 - 12:38 AM
        There are still several in the East Bay--check the YP for Oakland, Alameda and I'm pretty sure there's still some further south, too. Good ole classic thrifts, too, where you want to wear grubby clothes 'cause you're gonna get dirty digging through the bins...
      • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

        Mon, May 29, 2006 - 9:02 AM
        There are a few SVDP stores left-there's one in downtown San Mateo on B street and there's a SVDP outlet on El Camino in Redwood City. I find interesting stuff there sometimes and they tend to have 50% off clothing sales all the time. :>
        • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

          Sun, June 4, 2006 - 11:24 AM
          Thanks, both of you, for letting me know St Vincent's is still alive and well. A google/yp search is in order....

          :)
          • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

            Mon, June 5, 2006 - 6:13 AM
            St. Vincents is my current fave thrift store chain.
            • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

              Tue, June 27, 2006 - 3:57 PM
              Thrifting's getting bad in Seattle too! Our version of Saver's is getting way too expensive, and for one reason: because here, thrift stores are not for poor people. It's rotten but it's true. Every rack at the Value Village has some hipster or ebayer or vintage store buyer looming it like a little tight-pantsed vulture. I find that when i go out to the boonies, where wearing used clothes means you're poor and not just hip, you get a lot better prices and better selection. and more big sizes!
              • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

                Mon, July 17, 2006 - 5:09 AM
                There is also a SVDP on 3rd in Livermore (East Bay). They carry unfinished bookcases but generally the furniture is a little high. Valley Care Thrift is a block down from them and a bit cheaper but no firniture.
                • Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

                  Tue, July 18, 2006 - 10:29 AM
                  Over the years I have a list of Thrift Stores I frequent and I can expect certain items to be better priced in one store than another.

                  One store might have cheap books but overpriced clothing. Another has furniture they want to move fast so they almost give it away. A couch that is $100 at the Salvation Army will be $10 at the "cheap furniture" store.

                  Etc...;o))
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: good thrift stores are hard to find...

                    Tue, July 18, 2006 - 2:16 PM
                    I gradually assembled the general favorite and particular type of item lists of shops. Now I have to start all over 2300 miles away. It will be a good time exploring, but I've noticed there is a derth of GENTLY used items in the stores I've seen so far. Let the madness begin.
  • Unsu...
     

    It depends on what you're looking for...

    Sat, July 1, 2006 - 12:49 AM
    ...when it comes to Goodwill.

    You have to have a good eye, and you have to visit frequently. This was ideal when there was a Goodwill in the same shopping center as my grocery store. I check another one now, that is also close to a grocery store (but not as close or convenient).

    A few of my best finds at Goodwill
    Royal Albert Old English Roses mug, a buck
    A lovely black on white toile style Wedgwood bowl, a couple bucks
    A solid sterling silver (not plated) hammered picture frame, still in box, under $5.00
    A solid sterling silver Douglas Magnus "Big Silver" buckle set on a lizard belt, under $5.00

    So for about $15.00 I got a about $350.00 worth of perfect condition stuff.

    The cashmere sweater I putter around in all the time, I think that was $6.95??? The cashmere t-shirt I bought on one of the "all clothing-$2.00" sale days.

    I get all my shoes there. I think people wear shoes once and then donate them. ;)
    • Re: It depends on what you're looking for...

      Mon, July 3, 2006 - 5:36 PM
      Hey we have a St Vincent's in Mich too!
      They tend to cheese me off at the amount of things they throw away though.
      But they do give their stuff away every day before closing. If you can keep up with the people or get their earlier you can haul a bunch of stuff away for free!!, or cheap.
      This can be addicting though cause you can find great stuff everyday!

      I also love Salvation Army, I got clothes as cheap as 5 for $1.!!!
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Thu, March 22, 2007 - 5:12 AM
    Around here in western Massachusetts it seems that Goodwill is the highest of the "chain" thrift stores. They have lousy sales, one has if you spend ten dollars you then get an article of clothing for half price.

    However, the Salvation Armys around here are good. They always have a certain color tag that is half price on clothing and shoes. And some days they have family days where they will take 4 color tags and half price those.
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Thu, March 22, 2007 - 12:03 PM
      I live in Portland and we have several Goodwills spread throughout the metro area. Pricing fluctuates wildly. While the selection of brand name clothes is greater in Beaverton, where most residents have a higher income, you pay more for it at that store. In Gresham, where people tend to be middle or lower income, the clothing selection isn't as good, but the prices are better on everything. The main store, in southest Portland, has become the Hipster Goodwill: where "everyone who is anyone" shops for resale, or for costuming, or for Burning Man. Between the high prices and the picked-over selection, I don't even bother to stop by there anymore.
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Thu, March 22, 2007 - 11:14 AM
        Round these here parts, Goodwill marks their wares each week with a different color. Pink one week, green the next, then blue, etc. After so long, in an effort to keep the product moving, they'll have the first color (pink, let's say) at $0.99, and green (the second week's color) half off. Then the following week Green is the $0.99 color, and blue is half off, etc etc.

        You just have to know when to go, and what stores.

        Salvation Army has "half off day" on Wednesdays. If you can fight your way through the crowd, there are bargains galore to be had.
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Thu, March 22, 2007 - 9:44 PM
        Seems like a lot of thrift stores are trying to be department stores. they use those cool clothing racks, they size your items---I asked the cashier at Goodwill last time I was in there not finding anything, what happens to the junk? I needed some broken jewelrey, stray game pieces, doll heads, you know, junk? He said that everything goes to a central location, they pick out the good stuff to send to the stores and they box up the junk to sell at auction. so now I know where the junk went, but still can't get any. I need one of those dingy, dusty run by a guy with a cat stores. even the church thrift stores have closed down. yard sales, yeah I know, but it's been winter here in new jersey, and we don't do yard saless in the winter.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Fri, March 23, 2007 - 10:18 AM
    I go to Goodwill, mostly for books for my daughter and, one of my favorite scores, unopened jigsaw puzzles, but their clothes prices are getting too steep, especially kids' clothes. The Goodwill bins are still a fine adventure but, honestly, my favorite thrift store in Portland is run by the Union Gospel Mission, all of their profits go to feed the homeless and run their shelter downtown. I picked up a huge stack of books and some clothes for my daughter for $3.35. I thought that the cashier was joking when she told me the price.
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Sat, April 21, 2007 - 5:56 PM
      Yeah, this is a serious pet peeve for me. Goodwill has always been the worst, in my experience, but now, ALL the thrift stores I go into have similar problems. Especially with what I think of as "obviously worthless" items---- tupperware bowls with no lid, used underwear (how the fuck can you sell used boxer shorts for $1.99 when they were in a pack priced 3 pair for $5.00 eight years ago, when new & clean???!!!). A [badly] handmade wooden box with a broken latch, missing one hinge, kids stickers glued on for life...should be a quarter, it's marked "$9.99". Ripped clothing that should be a dime; it's marked $3.99. The same plastic dishes the One Dollar Store has, down the street--- marked $1.99 at the "thrift" store.
      I used to go thrifting maybe 3-5 times a week; now it's about once a month, for this reason. I buy a few books, an occasional gently used designer dress shirt (department store price $50, discount store price $10, thrift store price $4), and that's about it.
      • Re: certain stores making prices too high

        Sun, April 22, 2007 - 9:12 AM
        Yes...the glory days of thrifting are over...thanks to Antique Roadshow, eBay, yard sales, resale boutiques and "shabby chic"....;o)

        But it's still possible to find some good deals. I do much better shopping the independents than the chains...
        • Re: certain stores making prices too high

          Mon, April 23, 2007 - 12:53 PM

          In Portland we have "The Bins" an "as-is" Goodwill place where items that either wouldn't sell at their regular stores, or weren't chosen to be sold there, are selected to go. You can buy a shopping cart worth of stuff for about 10 bucks because it's by the pound mostly. You can furnish an entire house for about a hundred. Bed, couch, TV, the works. The worst place we have here is Value Village. Way way way overpriced.

          Swaz
        • Re: certain stores making prices too high

          Sun, June 3, 2007 - 1:43 PM
          Every time I go into a Goodwill or a Salvation Army anymore I can never understand whey the "Non Profit" thrift stores are so much more expensive than the "For Profit" ones like Thrift Town or Savers. They aren't doing anyone any favors. I was in Salvation Army in Berkley the other day and, I was looking for faux furs. They had this sorta cool pink one, but when I looked at the price it was $30.50!!! which was probably the same or more than it cost new. I have a similar one that I like better that I got at Savers for $8, the day they got it in, not even on sale, and I've literally bought 3 higher quality full length faux furs at Savers for the price of that one department store jacket at goodwill. In fact, the same week that I saw the $30 faux fur at Goodwill, I saw three REAL furs in perfect condition at Savers all originally UNDER $30 and on sale half off! Probably it's because nobody wears real fur anymore, but still, its ridiculous. If they go on sale for 99 cents I'm tempted to buy them and claim I didn't know that they were real.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Thu, May 3, 2007 - 3:26 PM
    always go to the old lady church thrift stores, they have no clue and price super low and their stuff is the shit (even if it smells like old people a little bit). In my old town we had a store that would have 5$ a bag sale, as in everything you can put in a bag for 5$. loved it.
    • Re: certain stores making prices too high

      Thu, May 3, 2007 - 9:24 PM
      the last thing i bought at the local catholic church barn sale was a fierce little 4" tall, multi-armed statue of kali, for 3 bucks.

      talk about not knowing what they had! ;-)

      i also got a fantastic adult-size, 3-tier, 2 layer, poofy, white crinoline petticoat for 2 whole dollars. it's the best kept secret in town.
  • Re: certain stores making prices too high

    Sat, June 23, 2007 - 5:18 PM
    After seeing too much nonsense (like a Harry Potter doll priced for $50.... WTF???) at the regular Goodwills, I found a Goodwill outlet. Same stuff they have in the normal stores, only all clothes are $1 each, and all ties/bests are $.50. I've gotten two London Fog trenches, a Dior tie, and 3 Banana Republic dress shirts... $4.50... love it.

    IME, Salvation Army has the worst prices, with many things in poor condition, yet priced close to what it would retail for new.

Recent topics in "thrifting"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
best find ever Unsubscribed 59 May 12, 2008